While this Kat was enjoying a well-deserved dinner with the new friends
she made at the launch of new copyright and business model centre CREATe in Glasgow, charming French-accented ARCEP commissioner Pierre-Jean Benghozi broke the news that Google and the
French government had finally reached an agreement which put an end to a 4-month long dispute over Google News.
As IPKat readers will remember, following a similar initiative in
Germany (here and here), in September last leading French
newspaper publishers had called on François Hollande's government to adopt a
law to force internet search engines like Google to pay for displaying their
content on services such as Google News.
|
At the beginning Google's arguments did not appeal particularly to French publishers ... |
Google was not particularly pleased with this initiative, and thought of
sending a dramatic letter to several French ministerial offices, in which it
threatened to exclude French media sites from search results if France had gone ahead with plans to set up what had already become known as the 'Google Tax' (here).
This move did not seem to worry French Government too
much, as in November 2012 Minister of Culture Aurèlie Filippetti said that the Government would have indeed
adopted a law requiring Google to pay royalties on the contents displayed on
its News service if this and the publishers had not achieved an agreement
before the end of that year.
|
... But then things changed ... |
Apparently, an agreement has been indeed achieved yesterday, thus following a similar settlement that Google concluded with Belgian
newspaper publishers a few weeks ago (here).
In any case, yesterday's agreement does not mean that Google will have
to pay for snippets of news content that appear on its search pages, clarifies France 24.
The terms provide in fact that Google will create a
EUR 60m (approx £ 52m) "Digital
Publishing Innovation Fund to support transformative French digital publishing
initiatives" [Merpel wonders whether perhaps too many
beautiful words have been employed here to express a concept which is certainly less
sophisticated but perhaps more comprehensible: settlement compensation?].
|
... So, all's well what ends well, muses cynicism-free Merpel |
In addition, as explained by Google Executive Chairman Eric Schimdt on the
company's official blog, Google will deepen its partnership with French
publishers to help increase their online revenue using Google advertising
technology at a reduced cost. Although it is still unclear how revenues will be
split, it is expected that most of them will go to French publishers.
The agreement builds on previous commitments to
increase Google investment in France, including Paris-based Google Cultural Institute, which opened in 2011 and is intended to
help preserve cultural treasures such as the Dead Sea Scrolls.
While debates over Google News and similar services are far from settled in Germany and Italy, it remains to be seen whether the French agreement could
serve as a model also there. In the meanwhile, Hollande cheerfully tweeted that "France is proud to have reached this
agreement with Google, the first of its kind in the world", reports BBC.
It would appear that a good way of preserving the Dead Sea scrolls is to put them in porous ceramic jars and to store them in dry caves in the arid Qumran region. It worked well for a couple of thousand years...
ReplyDeleteIt's nice that the dispute has been settled, but it's a bit of a sui generis settlement, presumably applying to Google only and not other search providers. What does this mean for smaller players who may want to enter the same niche in the future, who presumably now have the additional hurdle of a cosy agreement between Google and the French government? I won't say this is anti-competitive, but I hope that in due course other players will be given similar rights.
ReplyDeleteIs this settlement going to be a model for the latest EU "Licences for Europe" initiative?
ReplyDeletehttp://www.futureofcopyright.com/home/blog-post/2013/02/05/licenses-for-europe-a-step-forward-for-european-content-distribution.html