When does business not mean business? To what extent does the factual matrix play a part when trying to understand the terms of a settlement? How far will a court go to find a party just “got a bad deal” when agreeing co-existence? These are some of the questions Deputy Judge Justin Turner KC had to grapple with in the latest round of the long-running dispute between Thomas Pink (TP) and Victoria’s Secret (VS) ([2026] EWHC 2817 (BP), judgment here ). Background (Part I) Back in 2014, Birss J (as he then was) found that VS had infringed two trade marks owned by TP, through use of PINK by VS on its stores and articles of clothing sold in the UK and Europe ( [2014] EWHC 2631 , IPKat article here ) . The two marks held to be infringed were: 1. Community Trade Mark ( remember them? ) 3,949,906 for goods in classes 3, 14, 18, 25, 26 and retail services in Class 35: 2. The UK Trade Mark Num...