At the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, the patent firms in the most difficulty were those without established electronic files enabling people to work remotely (yes, those firms still existed in 2020). Today's Outlook outage shows that the IP profession now has the opposite problem, namely an almost complete reliance on electronic systems that may just decide to stop working. The EPO has indicated that "the Rule 134 on Extension of periods applies" to today's Microsoft 365 outage. However, there no details on what this may mean in practice, or how long an extension would be considered (if any, given that services are resuming). The Great Outlook Apocalypse of 2026 may very well be a wake-up call for firms becoming increasingly reliant on one software provider, the only answer to which is to build more redundancy into the system.
![]() |
No tea break for patent attorneys
The Microsoft services outage began on Thursday afternoon US time and quickly spread worldwide. Many Microsoft services were down, including most importantly Outlook, but also Teams, SharePoint and Copilot (although Teams seems to have largely survived). By this morning in Europe the outage was into its second day. Microsoft has put the issues down to a number of servers becoming unexpectedly unavailable and says that it does not believe malicious activity was involved (we wait to see what the final verdict on this will be). Services are now slowly coming back online, with Microsoft reporting partial recovery across regions.
For a lot of office-based workers, an email outage is a temporary inconvenience. The absence of the usual deluge of emails may even come as a relief. Unfortunately, patent attorneys do not have the luxury of relaxing with a cup of tea whilst IT sorts things out. The patent profession is one of those where there are absolute deadlines that simply cannot be missed, emails or no emails. Even for firms with back-up email provisions, the lack of Outlook is a problem, given that many deadlines require communicating with clients, agents and patent offices via Microsoft services. Many systems not directly Microsoft services are also inextricably linked, e.g. by multifactor authentication. However, the EPO online filing systems were reportedly unaffected.Running out of back-ups
The EPO has indicated that "the Rule 134 on Extension of periods applies" to the Microsoft Outage (Rule 134 EPC). This is similar to when the EPO extended all deadlines during the COVID-19 pandemic (IPKat) and in response to the general breakdown in electronic communication after the invasion of Ukraine (IPKat), subject to various limitations. Notably, the EPO has been preparing for such circumstances and very recently set out how some new Rule 134 safeguards will work from 1 April 2027 (OJ EPO 2026, A50 and A51).
Nonetheless, this Kat thinks we may still see some re-establishment cases at the EPO resulting from the Great Outlook Apocalypse of 2026, given that the Rule 134 provisions come with strict limitations. The test for re-establishment also remains very strict (IPKat). A party must show that the deadline was missed in spite of “all due care” required by the circumstances having been taken (Article 122 EPC). In practice that means truly exceptional circumstances, or an isolated mistake in a normally satisfactory system. The established case law is not that comforting on this (J 23/14, IPKat and J 05/18, IPKat).
The only way to reduce the risks associated with software and email outages is to build more and more redundancy into the system. In practice this may mean back-up email accounts that do not run on a single system or rely on a single provider. In the past, there was always the option of faxing documents, or even travelling to the patent office in person. However, these back-ups are becoming less and less useful, given that the ways in which you can communicate with the patent office are becoming ever more restricted to electronic methods. The EPO stopped accepting filings by fax in July 2024 (OJ EPO 2024, A42). Fax was replaced by a Contingency Upload Service (CUS), however this cannot be used to pay fees. Importantly, the EPO's automatic extensions for outages also only cover failures of the EPO’s own systems, not those of applicants (for which other provisions of may Rule 134 apply). The options for filing at the EPO are also going to narrow further from 1 April 2027, when electronic filing becomes the default. Very sadly, filing by hand at the EPO will no longer be possible. Also, none of this is of course helpful to a patent attorney waiting for an email with the copy of the spec from a client or foreign agent.
Final thoughts
The more reliant we become on IT systems, the more demanding our stress tests need to be, and the more redundancy will need to be built into the system. This is true for both patent firms and patent offices.

Are you certain that Rule 134 is applicable? The webpage says "Legal safeguards under Rule 134 may be available against planned and unplanned outages of online filing and fee payment services" but it also states that "MyEPO services are not impacted". This seems to leave it in doubt as to whether, for instance, difficulties in preparing submissions due to communication failures with clients or problems with Microsoft365 services such as Word would benefit from this rule, unless email failure is declared to be a "general dislocation in the delivery or transmission of mail" under Rule 134(2)?
ReplyDeleteI wonder whether the "all due care" provision under Article 122 might be brought to bear in such circumstances.
Separately, I wonder whether we will see a flurry of petitions for review in due course if the preparation and filing of last-minute Auxiliary Requests during Oral Proceedings (especially those taking place by ViCo) has been impeded by email and MS Word failures.
Potentially some confusion on this. It says "may" at the top, and then at the bottom in bold it says "What you need to know at a glance [...] Rule 134 on Extension of periods applies."
ReplyDelete