Never Too Late: If you missed the IPKat last week!

Keeping pace with the fast-moving world of IP isn't easy, but this Kat has gathered all of last week's top stories into one essential digest.

Copyright

A dedicated Kat hard at work typing up
 this week's top IP developments.

Söğüt Atilla-Aydın reported on the German Federal Court of Justice's (BGH) decision in Metall auf Metall VI, bringing a long-running legal battle to a close. Applying the CJEU's pastiche criteria, the BGH held that Moses Pelham's two-second sample in "Nur mir" qualified for the pastiche exception as an artistic dialogue across musical genres. This ruling provides welcome clarity and broader creative freedom for imitative and repetitive artistic uses.

Georgia Jenkins analyzed Nintendo’s $4.5 million default judgment win against Reddit moderator James C. Williams ("Archbox") for operating pirated Switch game shops. The US District Court found Williams liable for willful copyright infringement, DMCA circumvention violations, and breach of Nintendo's EULA. The ruling underscores the severe financial risks facing unauthorized modding and piracy platforms, alongside granting a permanent injunction.

International Trade & IP Law

Katfriend Seun Lari-Williams reflected on the WTO's 100th failed proposal to fill vacancies on its Appellate Body. He explored how this prolonged impasse has birthed an adaptive "multi-door" system of post-panel pathways, including the MPIA and Article 25 arbitration. Seun explained why this evolving procedural landscape matters deeply for international IP disputes interpreting TRIPS obligations.

Patents

Rose Hughes examined the Federal Circuit's decision in Wyeth v AstraZeneca, where a dose invention claim was invalidated for lack of enablement due to a self-imposed specification definition. The court ruled that by defining "unit dosage" functionally in the description, the patentee was obligated to enable that therapeutic effect across the claimed range without undue experimentation. 

Rose Hughes evaluated EPO Board of Appeal decision T 0977/25, where a grammatical ambiguity in an amended method claim resulted in an added matter rejection. The Board held that an unresolved ambiguity must be construed broadly to cover all plausible technical interpretations, requiring every alternative to have basis in the application as filed. This decision highlights how opponents can leverage claim ambiguity as an added-matter objection ahead of the EBA's pending G 1/26 ruling.

Trademarks

Marcel Pemsel reviewed two General Court judgments (Cases T-834/25 and T-835/25) confirming the rejection of Olymp’s colour combination and figurative mark applications. The Court reiterated that multi-colour stripe combinations on clothing generally lack inherent distinctiveness because consumers perceive them as decorative rather than source-identifying. Marcel noted that applicants seeking EU trade mark protection for color combinations must be prepared to prove acquired distinctiveness across the EU.

IP News and Events

Eleonora Rosati highlighted the upcoming ERA Annual Conference on European Copyright Law, taking place online from 25–27 November 2026. The program will cover key copyright developments, including CJEU case law, collective management, Gen-AI, deepfakes, and press publishers' rights. Readers of The IPKat can receive an exclusive 20% discount on registration using the provided VIP code.

Merpel McKitten issued a reminder for applications for GuestKat and InternKat positions starting in November 2026. Interested candidates must submit their complete applicationby midnight GMT on Sunday, 4 October 2026.


Image credit: Riana Harvey
Do you want to reuse the IPKat content? Please refer to our Policies section. If you have any queries or requests for permission, please get in touch with the IPKat team.
Print | Share by email

Comments

← Previous Post Next Post →