Plant variety rights enforcement continues to ramp up in China

In the last few weeks, plant breeder's rights enforcement in China has made headlines due to some recent court decisions about the protection of blueberry varieties. The cases illustrate the practicalities of how plant variety rights holders detect and assert infringement claims. Let's take a closer look at the decisions.

Background

Image by Beth Thomas from Pixabay.
The Australian breeding company, Mountain Blue Orchards, developed a blueberry variety named 'Ridley 1602', which is sold under the trade mark: Eureka Sunrise™. They obtained plant variety protection in many jurisdictions, including the EU, UK, USA, and China.

Sometime around 2014, the major American berry company, Driscoll's, obtained an exclusive licence to sell several Mountain Blue varieties in China for a multiyear period. Driscoll's originally planned to grow the varieties outdoors, but then switched to a proprietary system of planting the bushes in greenhouses in pots with a material made from coconut fibre, then used drip-irrigation technology to supply nutrients and filtered water.

The Infringement

Soon, many blueberry bushes were popping up on other farms, which used similar growing techniques and greenhouse designs. 

The Wall Street Journal reports that when undercover investigators from another blueberry company posed as farmers to buy sample plants from growers, they were shown WeChat messages by an employee of a Yunnan company, which confirmed that the company had "pulled some strings" to secretly obtain Eureka Sunrise™ plant cuttings from a Driscoll's farm. 

The investigators conducted DNA testing on the samples to confirm that they were Eureka Sunrise™ blueberry plants. The court accepted the DNA evidence and ordered the grower to destroy the plants and pay about US$ 23,000 in fees and damages. The new Chinese Seed Law entered into force on 1 March 2022, and based on its extension of the scope of protection to include harvested material, the sale of the blueberry fruits (as opposed to just the seedlings or other propagating material) was included in the assessment of infringement.

Photo from Australian PBR No. 6078.
In fact, two decisions on this matter were handed down in parallel. The decision from the Supreme People's Court (27 September 2026) confirmed that a landholder - not just the nursery operating on the land - would be jointly liable for the infringement. Meanwhile, the Guangzhou Intellectual Property Court (30 September 2026) held that related companies and a technical backer with an economic interest (despite claiming a "research" role) were jointly liable for the infringement too.

Conclusion

In 2021, China overtook the US as top global blueberry producer. This created a lot of alarm amongst berry breeders about unauthorised growing of the varieties, which has led to a flurry of enforcement activity. 

For example, just last week, the Supreme People’s Court published the summaries of "Five Typical Cases" of plant variety protection, which included the parallel litigation about the Plantas de Navarra SA blueberry variety named 'Plablue1542'. The decision in 2025 imposed punitive damages on the defendant, who was selling seedlings through WeChat and TikTok and seemed to be engaged in "infringement as a business" from its inception. 

Ever since the Seed Law reforms, readers may recall that plant variety rights cases in China are awarding larger and larger amounts in damages for infringement (see here and here), after the maximum amount of punitive damages available in cases of intentional infringement was increased. As much as the scale of infringement is growing, Chinese courts are trying to demonstrate that they will keep pace and strictly enforce plant variety rights.

Do you want to reuse the IPKat content? Please refer to our Policies section. If you have any queries or requests for permission, please get in touch with the IPKat team.
Print | Share by email

Comments

← Previous Post Next Post →