On 4 November, the UK Government published the outcome to the consultation on changes to the UK designs framework, covering issues such as examination and prior art searches, computer-generated designs, simplification of the (unusually) complex unregistered design system, and criminal penalties for unregistered design infringement. Katfriend Maciej Padamczyk (University of Liverpool) explains what this is all about. Here's what he says:
The outcome of UKIPO’s consultation on changes to the UK designs framework
by Maciej Padamczyk:
The UK Government has now published the outcome to the consultation on changes to the UK designs framework. The consultation, which the IPKat covered when it was announced, involved a substantial number of design law issues. Having received over 52 responses from stakeholders, the UKIPO made a series of recommendations:
1. Examination and prior art searches – discretion to conduct a search
The government acknowledged that, while anti-competitive applications are an issue for the users of the design system, this needs to be addressed without compromising its time and cost effectiveness. The planned reform gives the registrar the power to conduct a search and examination of designs on the grounds of novelty and individual character in some circumstances. The searches would cover a proportion of applications based on criteria that will guide the examiner.
2. No bad faith provision (for now)
For now, a bad faith provision will not be introduced. This is because: (1) the prior art search might already perform its function, and (2) evidentiary difficulties in proving bad faith. The government will undertake to define ‘bad faith’ behaviour and the evidentiary threshold required, and then decide whether to introduce the provision on this basis.
3. No opposition to designs
No opposition period for designs will be introduced. The stakeholders felt this would have added to time, cost and complexity to the application process.
4. Prior search in combination with bad faith and/or opposition
The government acknowledged the overlapping nature of options 1-3, which are all intended to prevent anti-competitive applications. A combination of prior searches and the bad faith provision seemed to have been preferred by stakeholders. Perhaps due to concerns over its redundancy – given prior searches – and the evidentiary difficulties involved, the government opted for searches while continuing to consider a bad faith provision.
5. 30-month deferment period
The reform will introduce a 30-month deferment period, bringing the UK in line with the EU and Hague systems. At the same time, to safeguard third parties, the government intends to ensure that some basic information about a deferred application (incl. the name and address of the applicant and representative, the filing date and priority date) will be published online.
6. Animated designs/Graphical User Interfaces (GUIs): easier application
The government intends to make it easier for applicants to file animated designs/GUIs. This will involve several changes jointly: increased file formats, additional guidance, amendments to the definition of a design and product, and the option for a description to be published as part of the registration.
7. AI-made designs: further work required
This issue arose due to the government’s concern about AI-generated designs which could make it ‘more difficult for human-created designs to obtain protection’. Different options were considered, including the removal of the existing provisions on computer-generated design (s. 2(4) RDA; s. 214(2) CDPA). However, as the outcomes of the consultation were not conclusive, the government will monitor the industry practice in the matter for designs and other IP rights.
8. ‘Simplifying’ design law
The UK design law is unusually complex, particularly following Brexit. While many users of the system find this complexity confusing, they are also concerned about losing the breadth of protection if any of the existing rights were removed. It appears no revolution is coming in this respect – the UK unregistered design right (UK UDR) will not be scrapped (CDPA). Instead, the government will continue to consider how to simplify the unregistered designs framework, first by intending to harmonise – as a minimum – qualification requirements and the term of protection. While there was ‘good support’ for harmonising the term of protection at 10 years, this would mean a large increase in the term for supplementary unregistered design rights (SUD) which could deter design registration. The details of the reform remain, for now, open.
9. No changes to copyright law
Because the consultation did not demonstrate a sufficiently robust consensus, the government decided not to intervene and to allow further clarity to develop through case law. The matter will remain under the government’s review.
10. Disclosure of SUD anywhere in the world (plus potentially a grace period)
Following Brexit, the UK introduced the SUD to mirror the protection previously offered by the Unregistered Community Designs across the EU (The Designs and International Trade Marks Regulations 2019). However, the geographic scope of first disclosure remains a challenge. SUDs are created only upon their initial disclosure in the UK; a first disclosure in the EU does not establish a SUD and may compromise UK protection altogether. This creates a practical hurdle for rights holders who must carefully coordinate global product launches.
The government considered several options, including the unilateral recognition of simultaneous disclosures and the introduction of a grace period for unregistered designs. The other options evaluated were creating a SUD following first disclosure anywhere in the EU (provided it comes to the attention of relevant UK trade circles) or following first disclosure anywhere in the world under the same condition. Ultimately, the government opted for a broad, worldwide disclosure standard to provide greater clarity, particularly for firms operating globally. The introduction of a grace period also remains under consideration.
11. No criminal sanctions for unregistered design infringement
While design infringement can have a serious impact on businesses, criminal sanctions must meet a higher threshold of proportionality than civil ones. The respondents raised a number of arguments against introducing criminal sanctions such as the fact that criminal courts are ill-equipped to deal with the uncertainty of unregistered designs. Stakeholders also pointed to the difficulty in determining the subsistence of the design, ownership, the duration and scope of protection. Given these factors, criminal sanctions for unregistered designs could have a chilling impact on legitimate design activity.
Nonetheless, the government reiterated its commitment to safeguarding designers and businesses against infringement.
12. Small claims track (SCT) for registered designs
Small claims track (SCT) at the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court (IPEC) offer smaller litigants a cheap and straightforward venue to defend their rights. Currently, registered designs are not accepted for the SCT – presumably due to the potentially complex nature of validity disputes. However, the consultation found several examples of cases where a registered design case was likely a good candidate for the SCT. This would have the advantage that parties could save time and money. It follows that the government plans a targeted and managed expansion of the IPEC SCT to include straightforward, lower value registered design cases.
![]() |
| Photo by Laura Chouette on Unsplash This Katfriend is looking into the future thinking what it holds for design law in the UK... |
Comment
This Katfriend is pleased to see the government publish its response, especially given the fact that he has participated in the consultation, alongside Jane Cornwell (University of Edinburgh), Sabine Jacques (University of Liverpool) and Georgia Jenkins (University of Liverpool). Our submission can be accessed here.
Overall, the response signals the government’s intent to adopt several useful improvements to the UK design system. Many of the solutions preferred by the government were present in our submission. We expressed our support for the introduction of limited searches. This option provides, in our opinion, a mechanism to start tackling anti-competitive filings and a basis for scaling up this work as and when more advanced search tools become available. It is also better tailored for its purpose than the proposed two-stage system, which could adversely affect all applicants. We also argued against the introduction of criminal sanctions for unregistered design infringement, emphasising the higher threshold of proportionality that a criminal law intervention must meet. The introduction of the SCT for small registered designs disputes is a more appropriate alternative that could improve enforcement for SMEs, subject to appropriate judicial control. Finally, it is good to see that the government rejected extreme ‘simplification’ of the regime, and instead decided to harmonise UDR and SUD provisions through qualification requirements and term.
Several other issues remain unresolved. This appears to be due to lacking consensus among stakeholders – the most notable example being AI-generated designs. Our response argued that extending legal protection to AI-generated designs challenges the human-centred foundations of IP, risks of over-enclosure of the design space, flooding it with AI-generated designs. Thus we supported the removal of the existing computer-generated designs provisions cited above. We also recommended clarifying the boundaries between the design and copyright regimes by removing copyright-protected subject matter altogether, or at the very least, removing barriers within s. 4 of the CDPA, and harmonising exceptions and limitations across IP regimes. Although the government has left this to be resolved through case law, it seems unlikely given the ongoing debate surrounding protectable subject matter that clarity will be achieved through the judiciary alone.
On balance, the government’s response is a positive development which promises to improve the design system in the UK without starting a revolution. Proposals that could have harmed the design system and its users were also rightly rejected. Nonetheless, the most doctrinally complex challenges – like its boundary with copyright – were not addressed. Given the scope of the latter subject, another consultation focusing on the matter would be welcome.
Do you want to reuse the IPKat content? Please refer to our
Policies section.
If you have any queries or requests for permission, please get in touch with the IPKat team.

Comments
Post a Comment
All comments must be moderated by a member of the IPKat team before they appear on the blog. Comments will not be allowed if the contravene the IPKat policy that readers' comments should not be obscene or defamatory; they should not consist of ad hominem attacks on members of the blog team or other comment-posters and they should make a constructive contribution to the discussion of the post on which they purport to comment.
It is also the IPKat policy that comments should not be made completely anonymously, and users should use a consistent name or pseudonym (which should not itself be defamatory or obscene, or that of another real person), either in the "identity" field, or at the beginning of the comment. Current practice is to, however, allow a limited number of comments that contravene this policy, provided that the comment has a high degree of relevance and the comment chain does not become too difficult to follow.
Learn more here: http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/p/want-to-complain.html