UPCKat: Proportionality defence against life sciences injunctions takes shape at the UPC By Annsley Merelle Ward on Sunday, November 01, 2026 automatic injunctions carve out exceptions injunctions Meril v Edwards proportionality Unified Patent Court upckat +
[Guest Post] Battle of the Bricks – AG Szpunar’s Opinion in Lego (C‑211/24) in Light of Nokia (C-316/05) By Marcel Pemsel on Monday, March 31, 2025 Advocate General C-211/24 CJEU Community designs designs Lego Peter Teunissen proportionality +
[Guest post]: The proportionality test in European patent law By Eleonora Rosati on Monday, December 11, 2023 book event Guest post injunctions Léon Dijkman patents proportionality +
What is the standard for preliminary injunctions before the UPC? By Annsley Merelle Ward on Friday, October 13, 2023 #IPKat #UPC 10X Genomics AmeriKat Injunction Munich patent injunction proportionality UPC injunction +
Amendment of German patent law: small step or giant leap for proportionality? By Léon Dijkman on Friday, July 30, 2021 §139 #IPKat 2021 reform German patent act Heat Exchanger injunctions Léon Dijkman Martin Stierle proportionality +
Keeping up with German patent litigation: Half-year case law review 2020 By Annsley Merelle Ward on Monday, September 21, 2020 #IPKat AmeriKat German patent law Haier half-year case review Huawei v ZTE i njunctions legislative reform Patent law pemetrexed proportionality sisvel +
Proportionality and FRAND in France - Paris appeal court upholds anti-anti-suit injunction but first instance court refuses PI in IPCom v. Lenovo By Léon Dijkman on Tuesday, March 10, 2020 #IPKat anti-anti-suit injunction C-159/02 C-170/03 ebay v mercexchange Enforcement Directive FRAND Huawei v ZTE Injunction IPCom lenovo patent proportionality SEP +
Hague Court of Appeal stays enforcement of patent injunction By Léon Dijkman on Monday, December 16, 2019 #IPKat injunctions patent patent injunctions proportionality stay of enforcement +