Be careful what you wish for: Hamburg court holds Wish liable for trade mark infringement

Online marketplaces prefer to be neutral: sellers sell, buyers buy and the platform merely provides the technical infrastructure. The reality more often than not looks different and the Louboutin decision of the Court of Justice of the EU (“CJEU”, IPKat here) provided a tailwind for brand owners to take action against platforms that are not strictly neutral service providers. In a recent judgment, the Higher Regional Court (“HRC”) of Hamburg (case 5 U 58/25, not yet published) held the online market platform Wish liable for trade mark infringement.

Background
The claimant, Jemella Group (“Jemella”), manufactures electric hair styling products, which it sells under the mark “ghd”. Jemella owns EU trade mark “GHD”, which was registered for, inter alia, “electrical hair straightening irons”.

The first defendant, ContextLogic Inc., based in San Francisco, operates the online marketplace www.wish.com (“Wish”) and is responsible for all technical processes. The second defendant, its Dutch subsidiary ContextLogic B.V., acts as the contracting party for registration on the marketplace in Europe. Payments are processed by Klarna on behalf of the Dutch subsidiary, and the payment notice refers to “your order with ContextLogic B.V.”.

Third-party sellers on Wish trade under pseudonyms rather than their company names. Offers provide no direct way of contacting the seller. The “Shop Info” contains details in Chinese characters, if any at all.

In 2019, Jemella noticed a large number of counterfeit “ghd” straighteners on Wish. Between October 2019 and November 2021, Jemella filed 142 infringement notices through Wish’s own “IP Violations Report System”, carried out six test purchases and sent several warning letters and finally sued Wish for trade mark infringement.

The District Court of Hamburg held the defendants liable for trade mark infringement, but only as secondary infringers under the German doctrine of Störerhaftung (meaning injunctive liability for a party that knowingly and causally contributes to an infringement and breaches reasonable duties to prevent or stop it). Jemella appealed to the HRC of Hamburg.

The Higher Regional Court's decision
The judges granted Jemella’s appeal.

1. Trade mark infringement 
The decisive question was whether Wish used the “ghd” sign itself. The judges left open whether Wish itself should be regarded as the seller of the counterfeit goods because, in any event, it had adopted the offers as its own.

According to the CJEU’s Louboutin decision, a platform operator uses a sign if a normally informed and reasonably observant user establishes a link between the operator’s services and the sign. This is in particular the case where the user might think the operator itself sells the goods in its own name and for its own account. The Hamburg judges read the words “in particular” as meaning that Louboutin is not limited to this scenario.

The judges assessed the overall picture:
  • the offers were presented uniformly, sometimes with identical texts and product images, while the reference to the seller was inconspicuous and the pseudonyms were sometimes random combinations of letters and numbers;
  • the identity of the sellers was not disclosed and it was not possible to contact them;
  • order confirmations and updates came from “Wish” (containing the Dutch subsidiary's postal address) and payment was made to ContextLogic B.V.;
  • the order status did not show the seller’s name;
  • the “shop assistant” chatbot displayed the Wish logo;
  • shipping was handled by “WishPost”, a group company whose use is mandatory for sellers in mainland China; for sellers in Europe, Wish offered “Fulfillment By Wish” with a central warehouse in Amsterdam;
  • Wish had influence on pricing by offering discounts;
  • Wish offered a returns and refund service, with warehouses in Germany for returned goods and granted platform-wide discounts;
  • Wish advertised that branded products could be bought on the platform and offered a targeted search for branded products;
  • Wish operated a verification programme for “authentic” branded products. Nevertheless, the search algorithm displayed products advertised under “ghd” when users typed “ghd”, without limiting results to verified genuine products. In fact, the results list did not contain a single original “ghd” product;
  • Wish reserved the right to set the final price for each product and keep any amount exceeding the seller’s price, to provide customer support at its discretion, and to sell uncollected returns for its own account.
To the extent that the CJEU requires knowledge of the infringement, the Court found that offering a verification programme for “authentic” branded products showed that Wish was aware that offers lacking the “seal of authenticity” were very likely to be counterfeit. The pricing pointed the same direction: a straightener that costs EUR 262 as an original was offered on Wish for EUR 35.

The defendants could not rely on the hosting safe harbour (Art. 14 E-Commerce Directive, now Art. 6 DSA) because they played an active role. Besides the factors listed above, the Court pointed to Wish's share in the sales revenue. The judges held that promoting offers and charging sales fees indicate an active role.

2. Unfair competition
Wish’s platform was lacking mandatory information required by national and EU law, which Jemella successfully attacked. Inter alia, the sellers’ names and (understandable) addresses were missing. While the Court did not require Wish to check every single offer manually, the platform must take structural measures, for example mandatory fields for the required information when sellers create offers and corresponding obligations in its terms and conditions.


Comment
1. The decision develops the Louboutin test further. The fact that users think the platform sells the goods itself is, as the HRC rightly held, just one example of when consumers may establish a link between the sign and the platform’s services. This is correct because the question is only whether Wish has “used” the mark “ghd”. “Use” means that the offer of the counterfeit products by a third-party seller forms part of Wish’s own commercial communication. The more services a platform bundles, the easier it is to justify that the platform “uses” the mark in its own commercial communication.

2. There is a certain irony in the court’s reasoning. Wish’s programme for verifying “authentic” branded products was presumably meant to demonstrate its commitment to fighting counterfeits. Instead, it served as evidence that Wish knew which offers were likely fakes and, worse, that it could have filtered its “ghd” search results but chose not to. Anti-counterfeiting tools are important but must be used consistently.

3. The judgment is also a clear indication of underenforcement of consumer protection law in Germany (and seemingly other EU Member States). Wish has been available in the EU for more than a decade and it took a private company to enforce basic rules of consumer law. 
 
The picture is by nhavantuonglai and used under the licensing terms of pexels.com. 
Do you want to reuse the IPKat content? Please refer to our Policies section. If you have any queries or requests for permission, please get in touch with the IPKat team.
Print | Share by email

Comments

← Previous Post Next Post →