The IPKat has received and is pleased to host the following guest contribution by Katfriend Rafał Sikorski (Faculty of Law, Adam Mickiewicz University), which questions the legality of creating multiple panels within a local division of the Unified Patent Court.
Here's what Rafał has to say:
"The Unified Patent Court (UPC) has now been operating for over three years. It has
proved to be a tremendous success. The court remains efficient in adjudication
of disputes relating to infringement and validity of traditional European as
well unitary patents. Certain trends are now visible in the operations of the
UPC. At first instance over 75%
of the disputes are decided by the German local divisions based in Duesseldorf,
Mannheim, Hamburg and Munich. Apart from the Dutch local division, local divisions in other UPC Contracting States get
significantly fewer cases. This is also the case with respect to the only
regional division, namely the Baltic division.
The distribution of disputes
raises concerns that the UPC will become in reality a German rather than a
truly European patent court. To some extent this comes as no surprise. Before
the UPC started to adjudicate patent disputes in June 2023, most patent disputes
in the European Union were being
decided by German courts. Prior to
the entry into force of the unitary patent package, the number of
patent disputes decided in Germany was between 60 to 70% of all patent disputes
in the EU.
 |
Photo by Levent Simsek via Pexels. |
The jurisdictional rules in the
UPC Agreement have strengthened
the position of German local divisions of the UPC. UPCA rules enable
forum
shopping. According to art. 33(1)(a) patentees may initiate infringement
proceedings in the local division of the
Contracting State where the infringement has occurred
or may occur or in the regional division, if the infringement has occurred or
may
occur in any of the
Member States establishing that division. Given the expertise and the relative
speed
of the proceedings
before German courts,
it is no
surprise that patentees are choosing to initiat
e proceedings in German local
divisions rather than in other local or regional divisions of the UPC.
During the negotiations of the
unitary patent package, EU member states were well aware of the likely negative effects of the concentration of patent
disputes in local divisions of one Contracting State. Experts
pointed to a number of such possible negative effects.
Firstly, such
concentration in the longer run could have an impact on the patent community in
the other Contracting States.
There the demand for patent services is likely to fall and innovators and
enterprises might be forced to seek counsel in other member states. Obtaining
advice in patent matters in another country and most likely in another language
might be more costly and thus less accessible. This in turn could particularly
harm small and medium enterprises.
Secondly, such
concentration might also favour one legal tradition over others. That these are
not purely theoretical concerns is evidenced by diverse approaches to patent disputes
over terms of access to inventions protected by standard essential patents.
Concentration might also result in preference for one procedural framework over
others, even though the UPCA and Rules of Procedure allow for significant
flexibility in this respect. Thus, concentration of disputes in German local
divisions has already resulted in preferring written and front-loaded
proceedings over oral argumentation and emphasis on cross-examination of
witnesses, including expert witnesses.
That member states were well
aware of the dangers of concentration of proceedings in the local divisions of
one of the member states is evidenced not only by history of the negotiations
leading to adoption of the unitary patent package but also by the wording of
provisions of the UPC Agreement itself which permitted forum shopping, while at
the same time placing restrictions on local division growth.
Firstly, the UPCA does not
subscribe to the idea of a fully centralized patent court. On the contrary, it
allows every Contracting State to create its own local
division and to designate its seat and language of proceedings (art. 7(3)
UPCA). Similarly, any two or more Contracting
States may create a
regional division, which can hear cases in multiple locations (art. 7(4) UPCA).
Secondly, art. 8 UPCA ensures multinational composition of the panels.
This in turn allows, at least to some extent, for different legal traditions to
be represented on any of the panels hearing the case. In the Court of First
Instance, panels are composed of three judges but depending on the number of
patent cases heard in previous years, these panels are composed of one or two
judges who are nationals of a Contracting
State hosting the local division and one or two judges from the pool of judges
who are from another Contracting State.
Thirdly, the Contracting
States agreed on a number
of additional restrictions for creating local divisions. So, whereas every Contracting State is entitled to its own
local division, the right to create further local divisions requires a certain
caseload. Thus, a Contracting State is entitled to subsequent local division
for every one hundred cases initiated per year in the period of successive
three years prior or after entry into force of the UPCA. Finally, and
probably most importantly, each Contracting State
is entitled to maximum four local divisions (art. 7(4) UPCA).
It is this last restriction that
has recently become a subject of controversy. The intention behind it was
clear. It was supposed to be a barrier against too heavy concentration of cases
in just one Contracting State.
As such it was supposed to protect various national patent traditions against
the dominance of the tradition of one
particular Contracting State. By aiming to protect the legal traditions of each
Contracting State, the
restriction on the number of local divisions also helps to protect the
necessary conditions for maintaining and developing national patent communities. The availability of such local patent ecosystems which
provide counsel in patent matters in a local language is particularly vital for
small and medium enterprises who might not be able to afford usually higher
costs in courts of other Contracting
States. More generally,
maintaining a balance
between various legal traditions and local divisions of all Contracting States is also important as it
is also helpful for securing and maintaining support for the UPC in both current and
future Contracting States.
The restriction on the maximum number of local divisions
in any given Contracting State could be quite easily circumvented if a
Contracting State was allowed to establish an unlimited number of panels in a local division thus creating
a mega division made of multiple panels. Clearly, if there is no limitation on the number
of panels, the restriction found in art. 7(4) UPCA would not be able to achieve its intended purpose.
Thus, the crucial question is whether the limitation on the number of local
divisions affects the number of panels that might be created. It
could be argued that the ability to add further panels allows for
efficient administration of justice by a particular local or regional division.
Since parties are, within the limits
defined in art. 33 UPCA, free to choose where to file their cases, it must be
possible to address the need for effective administration of justice by adding
additional panels in local divisions which are particularly popular with
parties initiating patent related proceedings.
To answer the question whether
there are any limitations on the number of panels that can be established within local divisions one has
to look particularly to the provisions of the UPCA and the Statute. In doing
so, it is clear that the answer is yes: there are limitations, and these
limitations foreclose the creation of new panels in a way that would circumvent
art. 7(4) UPCA.
Firstly, one should look
at the provisions of the UPCA. Art. 8(2) and 8(3) UPCA, with respect to local
divisions, and art. 8(4) UPCA, with respect to regional division, address
composition of the panels. These provisions speak of “any panel of a local
division” or “any panel of a regional division”, and similar wording is to be
found in art. 8(5) UPCA which deals with the selection of technical judges. The use of the
phrase “any panel” suggests
that there might be more than one panel in a given division. On the other hand,
this wording might also
refer to any of the panels in
any of the local or regional divisions without implying more than one panel per
division.
Secondly, one has to
analyse the provisions of
the Statute. Art. 3(4) provides that the Administrative Committee should
appoint the number of judges that would allow for creation of at least one
panel in each of the divisions of the CFI and at least two panels in the Court
of Appeal. This contradicts the wording of art. 7(4) UPCA which limits the
number of local divisions as it would allow for circumventing the limitation.
Additionally, art. 18 deals with setting up of local and regional divisions.
The Administrative Committee which sets up a division upon the request of a
Contracting State indicates the number of judges for the local or regional
division concerned (art. 18(2) Statute). That number of judges might differ.
This does not mean that there may be more panels than one, as the number of
judges might differ because some judges might be assigned for part-time
positions. Art. 19 in turn deals with the allocation of judges and cases within a division
to its panels. This also suggests that there might be more panels. This might
also be read in wider context of the UPCA and suggest allocation to any of the
panels within any of the divisions. More importantly however this also might be
read as a reference to a panel hearing a particular case.
Thirdly, none of the
provisions of the UPCA nor the provisions of the Statute provide explicit
competence to set additional panels. Art. 13(3) and 13(4) UPCA provide that the
President of the CFI and the Court of Appeal direct judicial activities and
management of their respective courts, but these provisions say nothing about
creating new panels. Directing judicial activities and management rather
implies purely administrative and organizational duties. Art. 15 UPCA on the
other hand entrusts management of the Court to its Presidium and specifies its
competences, but again says nothing about creation of additional panels.
One has to remember that UPCA is
an international agreement and that it should be interpreted in line with the
rules of interpretation defined in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties
(VCLT). Art. 31 VCLT provides that a treaty must be interpreted in good faith
in accordance with the ordinary meaning of the terms used in the treaty in
their context and in the light of its object and purpose. Art. 32
VCLT provides additionally preparatory work and circumstances of its conclusion
might also be used to confirm the meaning established when applying art. 31
VCLT or to determine the meaning when interpretation of the meaning established
upon application of art. 31 VCLT leaves the meaning ambiguous or leads to a
meaning that is unreasonable or absurd.
The interpretation of the UPCA
and the Statute creates a tension between the restriction to be found in art.
7(4) UPCA and a number of provisions of the UPCA and the Statute that suggest
that a local or regional division might host more than one panel. Given the
clear intent behind the restriction and the circumstances of the UPCA’s
conclusion as well as lack of provisions that would allow explicitly for the
creation of new panels, one has to assume that creation of new panels in a
given local division should not be allowed."
The present blog post, relates to the application of the VCLT when it comes to interpreting the UPCA.
ReplyDeleteAs far as the UPCA and the VCLT are concerned, it is manifest that the VCLT has been ignored when it came to mitigate the effects of the Brexit.
Contrary to the EPC, the UPCA does not contain any exist clause. The UK withdrew its ratification through a “Note Verbale” issued by the UK government. There has been no other form of withdrawal like a new vote of the parliament. It is therefore not even sure that the UK has effectively withdrawn from the UPCA.
In the VCLT two articles appear relevant:
First, Art 56 VCLT relates to a possible withdrawal when a treaty does not contain provision regarding its termination and which does not provide for denunciation or withdrawal. Such a treaty is not subject to denunciation or withdrawal unless:
- (a) it is established that the parties intended to admit the possibility of denunciation or withdrawal; or
- (b) a right of denunciation or withdrawal may be implied by the nature of the treaty.
None of those requirements apply to the UPCA.
Second, Art 62(1) VCLT provides that “A fundamental change of circumstances which has occurred with regard to those existing at the time of the conclusion of a treaty, and which was not foreseen by the parties, may not be invoked as a ground for terminating or withdrawing from the treaty unless:
- (a) the existence of those circumstances constituted an essential basis of the consent of the parties to be bound by the treaty; and
- (b) the effect of the change is radically to transform the extent of obligations still to be performed under the treaty.
None of those requirements apply to the UPCA.
The amendment of the UPCA under Art 87(2) UPCA
- It happens that Art 7(2) UPCA and Annex 2 of the Statute have been amended by the Administrative Committee of the UPCA under Art 87(2) UPCA, which has never been designed to overcome the effects of Brexit.
- Art 56 VCLT and Art 62 have been superbly ignored by the Administrative Committee of the UPCA.
As I have heard from a distinguished legally qualified person, if London=Milan, then red=green.
The amendment of the UPCA by the Administrative committee of the UPCA has been challenged by a party, ROKU, which requested a preliminary ruling to be referred to the ECJ. This was bluntly dismissed by the UPC CoA in its order UPC_CoA_288/2025.
In a decision taken before even the entry into force of the UPCA, and the opening of the UPC on 01.06.2023, the Presidium of the UPC decided the reallocation of duties meant to be dealt with in London. I have never seen a court disregarding the law by which it was set up. There as well, the VCLT was superbly ignored.
To invoke Articles 31 and 32 of the VCLT at this stage seems to me to be rather far-fetched. As the Presidium of the UPC and the Administrative Committee of the UPCA have up to now, carefully ignored the VCLT, it will not hinder those two bodies to take decisions as they think fit and continue to ignore the VCLT. If Art 31 and 32 VCLT should apply, then Art 56 and 62 should apply as well.