[Guest post] A €50 million Monet: Public domain, private property, and the hidden IP in an art auction

The IPKat has received and is pleased to host the following guest post by Katfriend Monica Ezsias, discussing relevant copyright issues facing a public domain artwork like the recently auctioned Monet’s Iris. Here’s what she writes:

A €50 million Monet: Public domain, private property, and the hidden IP in an art auction

by Monica Ezsias
In October 2026, Claude Monet’s Iris (1924–25) sold at Sotheby’s Paris for €50 million, making it the most expensive artwork ever sold at auction in France. The iris flower was supposedly one of Monet’s favourites. The painting, from the collection of Jeanne Schlumberger, had never been publicly exhibited since its creation.
Monet died in 1926, meaning his works are now in the public domain in the UK and EU. But what exactly does a buyer acquire when purchasing an original artwork? And if anyone can reproduce Iris without seeking copyright permission, what makes the painting worth €50 million?

The artist, the collector, and the copyright

Purchasing an original painting does not in itself transfer copyright in the painting. A collector may acquire a physical canvas, but the living artist will ordinarily retain copyright, unless the parties agree otherwise. It is possible for ownership of a physical artwork to change hands several times while copyright remains with its creator.
A copyright owner’s exclusive rights may be assigned in whole or in part, for example under Section 90 of the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (CDPA). Alternatively, an artist can grant a licence permitting specified uses.
Netflix, for example, licensed the right to adapt Roald Dahl’s work for several years before purchasing the Roald Dahl Story Company and thereby acquiring corporate control and the IP portfolio. This has allowed Netflix to exploit Dahl’s stories.
Robert Indiana, the artist behind the well-known LOVE and similar sculptures, transferred ownership of both his physical artwork and the subsisting copyright. When the title to his work was passed to the Morgan Art Foundation, in a separate agreement Indiana also assigned the IP, granting the Foundation the exclusive worldwide rights to reproduce and sell images.
The position with Iris is different. Since copyright in Monet's original work has expired, there is no subsisting copyright in the painting for the buyer to acquire. Under the ordinary life-plus-70-year term, protection expired at the end of 1996.
Per the Creative Commons’ attribution notice, the above image of Iris may be copied and shared so long as appropriate credit is provided, the use is not for commercial purposes, and no modifications are made.

Moral rights

French law recognises a separate and perpetual moral right – droit moral – which survives the expiry of the economic copyright. Under Article L.121-1 of the French Intellectual Property Code, authors have the right to respect for their name, status, and work; that right is perpetual, inalienable, and imprescriptible, and passes upon death to the author’s heirs. This means that the work’s entry into the public domain does not give a subsequent owner an unrestricted right to misattribute, mutilate, or otherwise distort: Monet’s heirs may object to treatment that infringes the artist’s moral right to attribution or the integrity of his work.

In the UK, the author of a copyright artistic work has the right to be identified as the author (Section 77 CDPA) and not to have his work subjected to derogatory treatment (Section 80). However, moral rights subsist only for as long as copyright subsists in the work (Section 86), i.e., moral rights are not perpetual.
Moral rights are not harmonised at an EU level: Directive 2006/116 is without prejudice to each Member State’s regulations on moral rights (Article 9); the position is reaffirmed in Directive 2019/790 (recital 37).

The hidden IP in an art auction

An auction involves considerably more than the sale of a physical object. Auction houses invest in photography, catalogues, and marketing to present artworks to prospective buyers. Each of these materials may invoke separate IP rights.
Consider the photograph of Iris used in Sotheby's online catalogue: although the painting itself is in the public domain, Sotheby’s photograph may attract copyright protection in its own right and requires separate consideration.

Can a faithful reproduction attract copyright?

This raises the question: can a photograph of a public domain artwork create a new layer of copyright protection, restricting access to and reuse of the underlying original artwork?
EU Directive 2006/116 permits Member States to provide related rights protection for sub-original photographs, i.e., those which do not meet the EU originality threshold (Article 6). Further, Directive 2019/790 provides that reproductions of work where the term of protection has expired is not subject to copyright or related rights, unless the resulting material is original in the sense that it is the author’s own intellectual creation (Article 14). This seeks to prevent faithful reproductions of public domain artworks from attracting new exclusive rights and recreating copyright protection where it has already expired – unless the reproduction is somehow of the new author’s own making.
In the UK, a photograph does not automatically attract copyright simply because skill and labour have been invested. Per Section 1(1)(a) CDPA, the work must be original. No longer an EU Member State, the UK is not subject to Article 14 as such. Nevertheless, the UK's originality requirement raises similar questions about whether a reproduction involves sufficient creative input to qualify for copyright protection. A creatively composed photograph may qualify for protection, whereas a faithful reproduction may not.
In THJ v Sheridan [2023] EWCA Civ 1354 [IPKat here], the Court of Appeal held that the first instance High Court judge had applied the wrong test of “skill and labour” to conclude copyright in the work. Instead, UK copyright law (post-Brexit) is to be interpreted in line with the CJEU requirement of “author’s own intellectual creation” per C-5/08 Infopaq [IPKat here], and subsequent EU cases elaborating that an author must express their creative abilities in the production of the work by making free and creative choices so as to stamp the work created with their personal touch.

If the painting is free to reproduce, why is it worth €50 million?

The expiry of copyright does not diminish the value of the original painting. Its price reflects factors such as scarcity, provenance, authenticity, condition, historical significance, and the reputation of the artist. There is only one original Iris, even if reproductions can be made and distributed without copyright permission.
Where a collector acquires an original artwork without acquiring any copyright in it, and where the painting is by a living artist, the artist may continue to license reproductions and commercial uses, even though the physical painting has passed into private ownership. Equally, a public domain painting can command an extraordinary price despite nobody having exclusive copyright in its underlying image.

A public domain worth protecting

The sale of Iris offers a reminder that ownership of an artwork, copyright in the underlying work, and rights in reproductions are distinct legal concepts. A painting can command €50 million while remaining free for the public to reproduce.
For collectors, auction houses, museums, publishers, and businesses, the practical lesson is to distinguish between ownership of the physical artwork and the rights needed to reproduce it.
Monet's Iris may now belong to a new private collector. Its image, however, belongs to a much wider cultural conversation.
Do you want to reuse the IPKat content? Please refer to our Policies section. If you have any queries or requests for permission, please get in touch with the IPKat team.
Print | Share by email

Comments

  1. Presumably similar considerations would apply to "digitally remastered" films, where old films have been restored to their original quality. I have seen such films that bear a copyright date corresponding to the issue date of the remastered film, rather than the date of the original film, but as the body of such a restored film per se can hardly be original, copyright would only appear to exist in any new leader or trailer, whose text would, for example, relate to those involved in its resoration and distribution.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

All comments must be moderated by a member of the IPKat team before they appear on the blog. Comments will not be allowed if the contravene the IPKat policy that readers' comments should not be obscene or defamatory; they should not consist of ad hominem attacks on members of the blog team or other comment-posters and they should make a constructive contribution to the discussion of the post on which they purport to comment.

It is also the IPKat policy that comments should not be made completely anonymously, and users should use a consistent name or pseudonym (which should not itself be defamatory or obscene, or that of another real person), either in the "identity" field, or at the beginning of the comment. Current practice is to, however, allow a limited number of comments that contravene this policy, provided that the comment has a high degree of relevance and the comment chain does not become too difficult to follow.

Learn more here: http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/p/want-to-complain.html

← Previous Post Next Post →