The IPKat has received and is pleased to host the following guest contribution by Katfriend Latha R. Nair (K&S Partners), which explores a recent judgment from the Supreme Court of Nepal. The case confirmed that foreign geographical indications with a reputation can be used to oppose the registration of conflicting trade marks that may mislead consumers in Nepal. The case provides some interesting comparison with the decisions in the Basmati litigation in Kenya, New Zealand, and Australia, which held that foreign GI registrations do not create a positive obligation for TRIPS members to protect the GI in the absence of the requisite local reputation or capacity to distinguish the goods.
Here's what Latha writes:
![]() |
| Mohini’s VISION and logo mark |
SWA’s main objection was against the description, “Finest Rare Scotch Whisky” found on Mohini’s trademark to describe its Nepalese product. In defense, Mohini argued, among others, that SWA neither had the locus standi nor a registration for Scotch as a trademark in Nepal to assert rights in the said term. Though SWA pressed for total rejection of the trademark, the DoI allowed the opposition only to the extent of barring Mohini from using the word “Scotch” on its label.
In its appeal to the High Court, Patan, Mohini contended, among other things, that the DoI’s decision undermined the national interests of Nepal’s domestic liquor industry. However, the High Court did not find the DoI’s directions to remove the word “Scotch” from the trademark to be erroneous. Noting that Mohini’s use of Scotch on Nepalese liquor could adversely affect the reputation and integrity of Scotch Whisky, the High Court rejected the appeal. Undeterred, Mohini approached the Supreme Court of Nepal, albeit unsuccessfully.
Some of the observations of the Supreme Court
(1) On the issue of SWA’s locus standi to file an opposition, the Court cited Nepal’s international obligations under the TRIPS agreement and the Paris Convention. Further, it noted that under and Section 18(1) of the Nepalese Patent, Design and Trademark Act, 1965 any interested party can oppose a trademark. The Court also relied on the 2023 judgment of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, India in the Scotch Whisky Association v. J.K. Enterprises, which held that SWA, an independent legal person, can seek legal remedies in its own name without making a local authorized user an indispensable party.
(2) On the issue whether Nepal is duty-bound to protect a GI notwithstanding the absence of a specific law, the Court held that the protection of “established GIs” such as “Scotch Whisky” and “Champagne” is a mandatory obligation rather than an option. The Court, thus held that, to protect the quality, authenticity, consumer confidence and the lawful rights of producers, the name “Scotch” must be accorded legal recognition and protection in Nepal for the following reasons:
- Nepal’s proposed law on GIs covered under the Industrial Property Bill, 2025 is currently under discussions. Ordinarily it is necessary to enact a domestic law for implementing TRIPS obligations. However, as per the maxim pacta sunt servanda, once Nepal is party to an international treaty, it cannot evade its obligations by citing the absence of a domestic legislation;
- If Nepal were to refuse protection to foreign GIs, there could be a possible prejudice to the long-term interests of Nepali products themselves in the international markets;
- If whisky produced in other locations were permitted to be marketed as “Scotch”, an ordinary consumer would be misled as to the true source, quality and origin of the goods. Such an adverse fallout cannot be disregarded. The State, thus, has a corresponding duty to prevent such deception; and
- The Scotch Whisky industry constitutes one of the principal pillars of Scotland's economy. So, unauthorized and uncontrolled use of Scotch would directly prejudice the market rights, economic interests and commercial protection of genuine producers.
(3) On the issue as to why “Scotch” should be protected in respect of Scotch whisky, the Court held that geographical names carry distinctive reputation and commercial goodwill in the market and that local producers cannot distort or misuse such reputation with the intention of deceiving consumers.
(4) Lastly, the Court relied on Section 9 of the Nepal Treaty Act, 1990 which stipulates that treaties signed by Nepal are applicable like laws. Having undertaken to comply with the provisions of TRIPS and the Paris Convention, the Court noted that Nepal cannot permit a domestic company to misuse an internationally established and protected GI.
Takeaways from the order
In conclusion, the order offers some takeaways for other GI stakeholders and general GI protection in South Asia as summarised below:
A trailblazer: Nepal is a South Asian nation with no law for protecting GIs. Of the eight South Asian nations, only six have a law for GI protection. Given this, the order is a trailblazer for Nepal and the region. Further, it is a morale booster for reputed foreign GIs that find it challenging to contain third-party misuse in Nepal.
The Supreme Court’s misgivings on Nepal’s progress in GI protection: The Supreme Court seemed concerned about the lack of a GI law in Nepal and the slow progress made by the country in enacting one in comparison with its neighbouring nations. With this order, it is hoped that the discussions on the Industrial Property Bill, 2025 would be quickly concluded to enact a law.
Ripple effects of the protection of Scotch in India: SWA has been protecting the property and goodwill in the name Scotch and names evocative of Scotch, in India, for over 50 years. SWA’s first success in a Court action in India was in 1971 in SWA v. Dyer Meakin Breweries Ltd before the Delhi High Court, when it held that 'Highland' when used for whisky was synonymous with Scotch whisky. It is no wonder that of the four precedents cited in the decision of the Nepalese Supreme Court, three are from India. The reference to these Indian decisions points to the rippling effect of the investments made by SWA in India going beyond the Indian market and aiding in addressing violations outside the Indian border as well.
An all-rounder: The order has managed to address GI protection from multiple angles such as rights of producers and consumers, treaty obligations of Nepal, lack of a national law and creating an inroad for enforcement for other GIs.
One question that remains though is what would happen to the 'not-so-established' foreign GIs in Nepal while the law is still sitting on the anvil."

Comments
Post a Comment
All comments must be moderated by a member of the IPKat team before they appear on the blog. Comments will not be allowed if the contravene the IPKat policy that readers' comments should not be obscene or defamatory; they should not consist of ad hominem attacks on members of the blog team or other comment-posters and they should make a constructive contribution to the discussion of the post on which they purport to comment.
It is also the IPKat policy that comments should not be made completely anonymously, and users should use a consistent name or pseudonym (which should not itself be defamatory or obscene, or that of another real person), either in the "identity" field, or at the beginning of the comment. Current practice is to, however, allow a limited number of comments that contravene this policy, provided that the comment has a high degree of relevance and the comment chain does not become too difficult to follow.
Learn more here: http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/p/want-to-complain.html