This is a review of the book, The Cambridge Handbook of Intellectual Property and Upcycling (CUP, 2026) edited by Péter Mezei (University of Szeged) and Heidi Härkönen (University of Turku).
The book provides a detailed overview of upcycling from a primarily intellectual property (IP) perspective. In four parts, it first defines upcycling and locates it within IP law and fundamental rights; second, addresses upcycling across various fields of IP, including patents, geographical indications (GIs), and unfair competition; third, analyses upcycling practices and territorial policy approaches; and finally, captures the broader picture by exploring discussions on AI, the right to repair, and the remedy of destruction of goods, as well as by evaluating upcycling through the lenses of economic and behavioural science.
The editors aim to provide a comprehensive review of upcycling and demonstrate how IP law should adapt to serve sustainability goals, particularly those pursued by the EU. As most contributors argue, IP regimes generally adopt an unwelcoming approach to unauthorised upcycling. As a way forward, the role that the doctrine of exhaustion can play emerges as a recurring theme across the chapters.
Part 2 looks at the relationship between upcycling and specific IP rights in eight chapters. Taina Pihlajarinne opens by proposing a model for assessing copyright infringement. She suggests balancing three factors assumed to exist in upcycling cases at varying degrees: (i) the degree of originality of the work used without authorisation for upcycling, (ii) the potential for directly extending the product’s lifespan, and (iii) the degree of sustainable creativity.
In chapter 4, Dana Beldiman, Stina Teilmann-Lock, and Anna Tischner approach upcycling from a design law perspective. They argue that upcycling should become a design strategy, where designers would turn waste into valuable products and consumer attitudes towards upcycled products would become more welcoming. In line with this proposal, they call for introducing ‘affirmative incentives’ into design law for the creation of sustainable designs.
Chapter 6 shifts the focus to patents where Neethu Rajam and Daniel Acquah evaluate the impact of patent law on social innovations and argue that, despite lacking ‘novelty’, the ‘new value’ offered by upcycled products to the society should be considered when assessing the patentability of an upcycled invention. Jochen Glöckner and Sarah Legner then discuss unfair competition, emphasising that it cannot be exploited to generate ‘windfall profits [for] producers’ from the use of their goods which have already completed their ‘intended useful li[ves]’.
In chapters 9 and 10 Pablo Fernández Carballo-Calero and Pilar Montero García-Noblejas discuss upcycling within the context of traditional knowledge and GIs, respectively. While Carballo-Calero demonstrates that, given traditional communities primarily attempt to secure protection for their knowledge and conserve their resources, honest upcycling practices which remain loyal to their knowledge would largely fall within the nature of their attempts; García-Noblejas identifies instances where unauthorised or improper use of GIs constitute infringement, and thus calls for the introduction of guidelines for upcyclers to avoid such risks.
Part 3 looks at territorial policies. In chapter 11, Daniel Acquah, Neethu Rajam, and Ama Opoku Acquah demonstrate African policy approaches to upcycling through case studies from Ghana and Kenya. In chapter 13, Martin Senftleben addresses the ‘overlap problem’ by reference to CJEU jurisprudence. He proposes that, when a product enjoys cumulative IP protection, rights holders should only be entitled to protection provided by the ‘common denominator’ of those rights, meaning that, if an upcycling practice is permissible under one IP regime, the right holder must tolerate the infringement of their remaining IP rights. This part also features discussions and policy insights from Asia, Latin America, and the Pacific Region.
Part 4 addresses the broader context. In chapter 17, Sabine Jacques compares upcycling with AI-generated outputs. Acknowledging that the comparison may seem ‘unconventional’ or ‘merely theoretical’, she draws, particularly, on AI authorship debates to advocate for a modernised understanding of creativity (that does not only include creating genuinely new things, but also involves recreating, reinventing, rediscovering existing materials) which extends naturally to upcycling. In chapter 19, Mikko Kaunisvaara, Rosa Maria Ballardini, and Emmanuel Salami critique the remedy of destruction of goods under patent law and conclude that modern approaches must evolve to accommodate sustainable practices. In the next chapter, Joost Poort demonstrates that IP rights holders lack a convincing economic justification for abusing their rights to prevent upcycling. Finally, Katarzyna Stasiuk, Anna Tischner, Stina Teilmann-Lock, and Dana Beldiman share empirical findings on consumer perceptions of upcycling. Their study reveals that (i) consumer awareness of upcycling is generally low, (ii) the appearance of the logo of a well-known brand on upcycled goods has limited impact on consumer evaluations (suggesting that the inclusion of the earlier product’s logo can actually prevent the risk of confusion – however, see, for example, IPKat here for a French court holding the opposite), and (iii) presenting an upcycled product as a collaboration between the upcycler and the well-established brand whose old products are upcycled generates more positive consumer response.
While the book platforms upcycling across many fields of IP law, it occasionally creates space for discussions on IP rights that already comply with sustainability goals, leading the reader to question whether these sections serve the book’s stated aim of showing how IP law should change to align with sustainable practices. Additionally, most chapters open with a definition of upcycling. Although this may be helpful for readers referring to some chapters of the book – allowing them to become familiar with the term and the relevant IP-related concerns that may arise from the practice – it may feel repetitive for those reading the book from cover to cover, especially given the thorough exploration of upcycling in the first chapter.
Whether approaching the topic from a copyright, GI, patent, unfair competition, or even behavioural science perspective, the book offers something for everyone, making it a useful and comprehensive resource on upcycling and IP.
Extent: 410 pages
Format: Hardcover
ISBN: 9781009685108
The book provides a detailed overview of upcycling from a primarily intellectual property (IP) perspective. In four parts, it first defines upcycling and locates it within IP law and fundamental rights; second, addresses upcycling across various fields of IP, including patents, geographical indications (GIs), and unfair competition; third, analyses upcycling practices and territorial policy approaches; and finally, captures the broader picture by exploring discussions on AI, the right to repair, and the remedy of destruction of goods, as well as by evaluating upcycling through the lenses of economic and behavioural science.
The editors aim to provide a comprehensive review of upcycling and demonstrate how IP law should adapt to serve sustainability goals, particularly those pursued by the EU. As most contributors argue, IP regimes generally adopt an unwelcoming approach to unauthorised upcycling. As a way forward, the role that the doctrine of exhaustion can play emerges as a recurring theme across the chapters.
A closer look at some chapters of the book
Part 1 comprises two chapters setting the scene for upcycling. In the first chapter, Péter Mezei and Heidi Härkönen provide an IP-focused definition of upcycling, identify four key concerns for legislative action, and advocate for the doctrine of exhaustion, alongside three alternatives: an upcycling exception, constructive legal interpretation of existing norms, and soft law solutions. In the second chapter, Daniël Jongsma tackles a ‘deceptively simple question’: whether EU fundamental rights have horizontal effect to prevent IP rights from hindering upcycling, given that rights holders actively enforce their rights against upcyclers’ sustainable, circular methods.Part 2 looks at the relationship between upcycling and specific IP rights in eight chapters. Taina Pihlajarinne opens by proposing a model for assessing copyright infringement. She suggests balancing three factors assumed to exist in upcycling cases at varying degrees: (i) the degree of originality of the work used without authorisation for upcycling, (ii) the potential for directly extending the product’s lifespan, and (iii) the degree of sustainable creativity.
![]() |
| Pihlajarinne's suggested model (taken from p.63 of the book) where A suggests copyright infringement while B and C can support a finding of non-infringement. |
In chapter 4, Dana Beldiman, Stina Teilmann-Lock, and Anna Tischner approach upcycling from a design law perspective. They argue that upcycling should become a design strategy, where designers would turn waste into valuable products and consumer attitudes towards upcycled products would become more welcoming. In line with this proposal, they call for introducing ‘affirmative incentives’ into design law for the creation of sustainable designs.
Chapter 6 shifts the focus to patents where Neethu Rajam and Daniel Acquah evaluate the impact of patent law on social innovations and argue that, despite lacking ‘novelty’, the ‘new value’ offered by upcycled products to the society should be considered when assessing the patentability of an upcycled invention. Jochen Glöckner and Sarah Legner then discuss unfair competition, emphasising that it cannot be exploited to generate ‘windfall profits [for] producers’ from the use of their goods which have already completed their ‘intended useful li[ves]’.
In chapters 9 and 10 Pablo Fernández Carballo-Calero and Pilar Montero García-Noblejas discuss upcycling within the context of traditional knowledge and GIs, respectively. While Carballo-Calero demonstrates that, given traditional communities primarily attempt to secure protection for their knowledge and conserve their resources, honest upcycling practices which remain loyal to their knowledge would largely fall within the nature of their attempts; García-Noblejas identifies instances where unauthorised or improper use of GIs constitute infringement, and thus calls for the introduction of guidelines for upcyclers to avoid such risks.
Part 3 looks at territorial policies. In chapter 11, Daniel Acquah, Neethu Rajam, and Ama Opoku Acquah demonstrate African policy approaches to upcycling through case studies from Ghana and Kenya. In chapter 13, Martin Senftleben addresses the ‘overlap problem’ by reference to CJEU jurisprudence. He proposes that, when a product enjoys cumulative IP protection, rights holders should only be entitled to protection provided by the ‘common denominator’ of those rights, meaning that, if an upcycling practice is permissible under one IP regime, the right holder must tolerate the infringement of their remaining IP rights. This part also features discussions and policy insights from Asia, Latin America, and the Pacific Region.
Part 4 addresses the broader context. In chapter 17, Sabine Jacques compares upcycling with AI-generated outputs. Acknowledging that the comparison may seem ‘unconventional’ or ‘merely theoretical’, she draws, particularly, on AI authorship debates to advocate for a modernised understanding of creativity (that does not only include creating genuinely new things, but also involves recreating, reinventing, rediscovering existing materials) which extends naturally to upcycling. In chapter 19, Mikko Kaunisvaara, Rosa Maria Ballardini, and Emmanuel Salami critique the remedy of destruction of goods under patent law and conclude that modern approaches must evolve to accommodate sustainable practices. In the next chapter, Joost Poort demonstrates that IP rights holders lack a convincing economic justification for abusing their rights to prevent upcycling. Finally, Katarzyna Stasiuk, Anna Tischner, Stina Teilmann-Lock, and Dana Beldiman share empirical findings on consumer perceptions of upcycling. Their study reveals that (i) consumer awareness of upcycling is generally low, (ii) the appearance of the logo of a well-known brand on upcycled goods has limited impact on consumer evaluations (suggesting that the inclusion of the earlier product’s logo can actually prevent the risk of confusion – however, see, for example, IPKat here for a French court holding the opposite), and (iii) presenting an upcycled product as a collaboration between the upcycler and the well-established brand whose old products are upcycled generates more positive consumer response.
Closing remarks
The book provides a holistic analysis of upcycling. While previous discussions have focused on copyright and trade mark law, this volume completes the picture by introducing readers to less explored fields, such as patents. A key strength of the book is its empirical data on consumer awareness and perceptions. These findings are highly valuable: they not only support calls to shift consumer attitudes towards upcycling and the theoretical discussions and suggestions to reform IP law, but also challenge judicial assumptions, particularly regarding the risk of consumer confusion in trade mark disputes arising from unauthorised upcycling.While the book platforms upcycling across many fields of IP law, it occasionally creates space for discussions on IP rights that already comply with sustainability goals, leading the reader to question whether these sections serve the book’s stated aim of showing how IP law should change to align with sustainable practices. Additionally, most chapters open with a definition of upcycling. Although this may be helpful for readers referring to some chapters of the book – allowing them to become familiar with the term and the relevant IP-related concerns that may arise from the practice – it may feel repetitive for those reading the book from cover to cover, especially given the thorough exploration of upcycling in the first chapter.
Whether approaching the topic from a copyright, GI, patent, unfair competition, or even behavioural science perspective, the book offers something for everyone, making it a useful and comprehensive resource on upcycling and IP.
Details
Publisher: Cambridge University Press, 2026Extent: 410 pages
Format: Hardcover
ISBN: 9781009685108
Do you want to reuse the IPKat content? Please refer to our
Policies section.
If you have any queries or requests for permission, please get in touch with the IPKat team.


Comments
Post a Comment
All comments must be moderated by a member of the IPKat team before they appear on the blog. Comments will not be allowed if the contravene the IPKat policy that readers' comments should not be obscene or defamatory; they should not consist of ad hominem attacks on members of the blog team or other comment-posters and they should make a constructive contribution to the discussion of the post on which they purport to comment.
It is also the IPKat policy that comments should not be made completely anonymously, and users should use a consistent name or pseudonym (which should not itself be defamatory or obscene, or that of another real person), either in the "identity" field, or at the beginning of the comment. Current practice is to, however, allow a limited number of comments that contravene this policy, provided that the comment has a high degree of relevance and the comment chain does not become too difficult to follow.
Learn more here: http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/p/want-to-complain.html