Human or AI creation? How to prove authorship

AI can create almost anything that humans can create, including pictures, texts and entire songs. But how do you know whether, e.g., the lyrics to a song have been conceived by a human or an AI? If, in a copyright dispute, the human authorship of lyrics is disputed, who bears the burden of proof and how do you establish that the lyrics have been created by a human or an AI? These questions have been addressed by the Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main in a recent decision (case 11 U 2/26).

Background

In July 2025, the plaintiff’s producer published a song online. The plaintiff claimed to have authored the original lyrics for this song. In the production process, the plaintiff’s producer utilized SunoAI (an AI tool that creates music, see IPKat here) at the very least for the creation of the accompanying music.

In early October 2025, contact took place between the plaintiff’s producer and the management of an artist during which the song created by the plaintiff’s producer was discussed.

The artist’s record label submitted the plaintiff’s producer’s song to a music expert. In his expert report, he concluded that there were numerous indications that the plaintiff’s song had been generated using AI.

The defendant, who handled the digital distribution of the artist’s songs, released two different versions of a song by the artist via Spotify and other services, both incorporating the lyrics of the song published by the plaintiff’s producer.

On Instagram, the artist promoted her song with, among other things, the phrase: “Everyone get in here before the song gets taken down!!!!” On Twitch, she stated that she was going on tour with a song that did not belong to her.

The plaintiff claimed that she wrote the lyrics for the song without the help of AI and filed for a preliminary injunction against the defendant because of copyright infringement. The artist’s record label intervened on the side of the defendant. The District Court of Frankfurt am Main granted the preliminary injunction. The defendant appealed.


The Higher Regional Court’s decision

The Court confirmed the essence of the preliminary injunction.

1. The initial lyrics created by the plaintiff (referred to as “raw version”) were deemed to constitute a literary work within the meaning of Section 2(1) no. 1 German Copyright Act. The judges recalled the case law of the Court of Justice of the EU (“CJEU”), according to which “work” is an autonomous term under EU law and comprises two constituent elements: first, it must be the author’s own intellectual creation, meaning that it must reflect the author’s personality. Second, the classification as a “work” is reserved for elements that give expression to such a creation.

The Court found that the language used in the “raw version” was concise, highly explicit, partly colloquial and striking. The chosen linguistic style served, in a distinctive manner, to underscore the development of the protagonist as depicted in the lyrics.

The Court emphasized that it was unnecessary to determine the precise extent of AI involvement in later versions of the lyrics because the essential creative elements of the human-created raw version remained identifiable in the published song.

2. The judges held that, in principle, the claimant has to establish that the work was created by a human. If a work can be created by AI, there is no room for generally assuming that a human created it. Some authors in legal literature require that the defendant must first present specific indications that the output is AI-generated and thus ineligible for protection. Such indications might include, for example, a volume of work that is quantitatively unrealistic, statements by the claimant suggesting the use of AI, features within the work itself pointing to machine generation, or the results of an analysis by an “AI detector”. The Court left open whether this notion in legal literature is correct because the intervening record label had introduced such specific indications by the expert opinion it had commissioned. Under these circumstances, the plaintiff had to explain in detail why the work constituted a protectable human creation.

The judges found the plaintiff’s account of the creation of the lyrics convincing. The plaintiff had submitted two drafts of the lyrics and explained their origin. The implementation of the final lyrics in the song produced by the plaintiff’s producer did not change the lyrics. It merely smoothed the pronunciation of individual words, adjusted the emphasis or fine-tuned the timing. The Court deemed this to be a coherent and plausible account of a personal, original creation.

The credibility of the plaintiff’s averments was not deemed undermined by the arguments in the expert report. The judges found the indicators cited by the expert to suggest that the lyrics were AI-generated unconvincing:
  • The expert characterised it as “noteworthy” that the text explicitly mentions that a story is told. The Court held that such a stylistic device has long been established.
  • The expert characterised the text as “unusual”, specifically with respect to the extended chorus, which appears in its entirety only once. However, he acknowledged that such an “idea” could certainly originate from a human.
  • Overall, the expert noted a lack of a coherent narrative thread, describing the work as excessive, including its attempt to explore new approaches. The Court countered that AI systems typically rely on pattern recognition and tend to utilize established patterns rather than forging new paths.
  • Similarly, the absence of poetic linguistic devices did not, in the Court’s opinion, suggest AI generation. In fact, an AI application based on pattern recognition would be well-equipped to employ and would likely utilize known poetic devices.
  • The expert’s observation that the sentences, when combined, sometimes make “little sense” was unconvincing as an indicator of AI generation. The judges perceived a narrative arc in the lyrics. The expert himself highlighted an underlying “Cinderella” plot. He inferred without explanation that some sentences were sequenced based on probability. The lack of an explanation for this inference made the whole argument unconvincing.
  • The expert scanned the text using the tool “GPTZero”, which suggested that 77% of the text originated from an AI. However, this conclusion was not substantiated.
For these reasons, the Court held that the plaintiff created the lyrics herself.

3. Since the contested song reproduced a significant part of the plaintiff’s lyrics, the Court upheld the copyright infringement claim.

Comment

It can be expected that the “AI defence” will become the standard in copyright cases dealing with works that can be AI-generated. The question of burden of proof and how to prove human authorship will be decisive.

For authors of any type of texts, it is important to keep manuscripts of drafts. If the work is not conceived within a day, changes to the text should be dated and saved on a regular basis in new files so that the process of creating the work can be shown to the court if disputed.
Do you want to reuse the IPKat content? Please refer to our Policies section. If you have any queries or requests for permission, please get in touch with the IPKat team.
Print | Share by email

Comments

← Previous Post Next Post →