How much publicity is needed before a trade mark applicant can no longer credibly deny knowledge of another party’s sign? In decision R2260/2025-4, the Board of Appeal (“BoA”) of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (“EUIPO”) had little difficulty concluding that the applicant for the EU trade mark “Truth Social” was fully aware of the highly publicised plans of Donald J. Trump to launch a social media platform under the same name.
Background
On 21 October 2021, a private individual applied for registration of EU trade mark “Truth Social” for the following services:
Class 35: Advertising, marketing and promotional services.
Class 42: IT services; design services; scientific technological services [sic!]; testing, authentication and quality control.
Class 45: Online social networking services; computer dating services.
After the mark’s registration in 2022, T Media Tech LLC (“TMT”) filed an invalidity application based on bad faith. TMT is an American media and technology company founded by Donald J. Trump and operating the social media platform “TRUTH SOCIAL”. The creation of this platform has been subject to extensive media coverage globally. The launch of “TRUTH SOCIAL” was announced in a press release from 20 October 2021, in which readers were invited to visit the website www.truthsocial.com (owned and controlled by TMT) and which announced that the platform was “available for Pre-Order in the Apple App store”. Further, an affiliate of TMT had filed a US trade mark “TRUTH SOCIAL” in July 2021.
Background
On 21 October 2021, a private individual applied for registration of EU trade mark “Truth Social” for the following services:
Class 35: Advertising, marketing and promotional services.
Class 42: IT services; design services; scientific technological services [sic!]; testing, authentication and quality control.
Class 45: Online social networking services; computer dating services.
After the mark’s registration in 2022, T Media Tech LLC (“TMT”) filed an invalidity application based on bad faith. TMT is an American media and technology company founded by Donald J. Trump and operating the social media platform “TRUTH SOCIAL”. The creation of this platform has been subject to extensive media coverage globally. The launch of “TRUTH SOCIAL” was announced in a press release from 20 October 2021, in which readers were invited to visit the website www.truthsocial.com (owned and controlled by TMT) and which announced that the platform was “available for Pre-Order in the Apple App store”. Further, an affiliate of TMT had filed a US trade mark “TRUTH SOCIAL” in July 2021.
The invalidity application was successful before the EUIPO's Cancellation Division. The owner of the contested mark filed an appeal with the BoA.
The Board of Appeal’s decision
The BoA dismissed the appeal and confirmed that the contested application was filed in bad faith.
First, the BoA found that TMT and its affiliate had been using the sign “TRUTH SOCIAL” prior to the filing date of the contested mark. Moreover, the sign enjoyed protection through the US filing as well as a reputation on account of the extensive media coverage.
Next, the BoA held that the sign of the contested mark and the sign pre-used and pre-registered by TMT and its affiliate were identical. The services in class 45 of the contested mark (“online social networking services”) were identical to TMT’s services. With respect to the other services in classes 35, 42 and 45 of the contested mark, the BoA referred to Advocate General Kokott’s opinion in STYLO & KOTON (IPKat here), in which she found that dividing an application into a part filed in bad faith and a part filed in good faith could incentivise applications for a larger list of goods and services than is justified by the actual intended uses. The fact that an application was filed for goods and services in respect of which the trade mark owner knew or should have known that identical or similar trade marks existed may in any event be an important indication that the application for the other goods or services was also filed in bad faith. It is then for the owner of the contested mark to present, in respect of those other goods or services, a commercial logic of its use.
Due to the significant media coverage of Donald J. Trump’s announcement to launch “Truth Social” and the fact that the trade mark owner was a businessman who was expected to follow business, economic and political developments capable of affecting his interests and investments, the BoA found the owner’s argument implausible that he had no knowledge of the (intended) use of “Truth Social” by Donald J. Trump and TMT, respectively, as well as TMT’s affiliate’s US registration. Moreover, the trade mark owner did not explain how he came to select “Truth Social” as a trade mark for “online social networking services”.
The final nails in the trade mark owner’s coffin were the cease-and-desist letters he sent to TMT and its affiliate Trump Media & Technology Group Corp. and follow-up communication offering to transfer the contested mark to Trump Media & Technology Group Corp. in return for “adequate compensation”. The trade mark owner stated that a transfer would be in the interests of both parties, as it would avoid “costly and public legal proceedings”. He also referred to the “stakes and potential implications of this matter, especially in light of the upcoming American elections”. The tone and context of these letters showed, in the BoA’s opinion, the trade mark owner’s intention to exert pressure on Trump Media & Technology Group Corp.
The BoA also noted that the trade mark owner had not used the mark since its registration. While the absence of use during the five-year grace period was deemed legitimate, the trade mark owner had not credibly explained the absence of commercial activity or at least any plans or preparatory activities for the future use of the contested mark.
The Board of Appeal’s decision
The BoA dismissed the appeal and confirmed that the contested application was filed in bad faith.
First, the BoA found that TMT and its affiliate had been using the sign “TRUTH SOCIAL” prior to the filing date of the contested mark. Moreover, the sign enjoyed protection through the US filing as well as a reputation on account of the extensive media coverage.
Next, the BoA held that the sign of the contested mark and the sign pre-used and pre-registered by TMT and its affiliate were identical. The services in class 45 of the contested mark (“online social networking services”) were identical to TMT’s services. With respect to the other services in classes 35, 42 and 45 of the contested mark, the BoA referred to Advocate General Kokott’s opinion in STYLO & KOTON (IPKat here), in which she found that dividing an application into a part filed in bad faith and a part filed in good faith could incentivise applications for a larger list of goods and services than is justified by the actual intended uses. The fact that an application was filed for goods and services in respect of which the trade mark owner knew or should have known that identical or similar trade marks existed may in any event be an important indication that the application for the other goods or services was also filed in bad faith. It is then for the owner of the contested mark to present, in respect of those other goods or services, a commercial logic of its use.
Due to the significant media coverage of Donald J. Trump’s announcement to launch “Truth Social” and the fact that the trade mark owner was a businessman who was expected to follow business, economic and political developments capable of affecting his interests and investments, the BoA found the owner’s argument implausible that he had no knowledge of the (intended) use of “Truth Social” by Donald J. Trump and TMT, respectively, as well as TMT’s affiliate’s US registration. Moreover, the trade mark owner did not explain how he came to select “Truth Social” as a trade mark for “online social networking services”.
The final nails in the trade mark owner’s coffin were the cease-and-desist letters he sent to TMT and its affiliate Trump Media & Technology Group Corp. and follow-up communication offering to transfer the contested mark to Trump Media & Technology Group Corp. in return for “adequate compensation”. The trade mark owner stated that a transfer would be in the interests of both parties, as it would avoid “costly and public legal proceedings”. He also referred to the “stakes and potential implications of this matter, especially in light of the upcoming American elections”. The tone and context of these letters showed, in the BoA’s opinion, the trade mark owner’s intention to exert pressure on Trump Media & Technology Group Corp.
The BoA also noted that the trade mark owner had not used the mark since its registration. While the absence of use during the five-year grace period was deemed legitimate, the trade mark owner had not credibly explained the absence of commercial activity or at least any plans or preparatory activities for the future use of the contested mark.
Comment
The decision is another important brick in the wall of bad faith case law. Screening the news for product launch announcements and registering identical trade marks in the hope of benefiting from being the first to file the announced trade mark is not a promising business model.
Trade mark owners should also consider making use of the six-month period to claim priority under Art. 4(C)(1) Paris Convention. TMT’s affiliate could have filed for protection in the EU and claimed priority from its US registration for “Truth Social” even after the bad faith application had been filed because the six-month period was not expired at the filing date. This would have made an invalidity application (or an opposition) considerably easier.
Even if earlier rights exist, a bad faith invalidity application should be considered in addition to opposition or invalidity proceedings based on earlier rights if the contested mark is also registered for goods and services that are dissimilar to those of the earlier mark. As the decision shows, a bad faith application can have broader consequences and result in the cancellation of goods and services that are dissimilar to those of the “earlier mark”.
The decision is another important brick in the wall of bad faith case law. Screening the news for product launch announcements and registering identical trade marks in the hope of benefiting from being the first to file the announced trade mark is not a promising business model.
Trade mark owners should also consider making use of the six-month period to claim priority under Art. 4(C)(1) Paris Convention. TMT’s affiliate could have filed for protection in the EU and claimed priority from its US registration for “Truth Social” even after the bad faith application had been filed because the six-month period was not expired at the filing date. This would have made an invalidity application (or an opposition) considerably easier.
Even if earlier rights exist, a bad faith invalidity application should be considered in addition to opposition or invalidity proceedings based on earlier rights if the contested mark is also registered for goods and services that are dissimilar to those of the earlier mark. As the decision shows, a bad faith application can have broader consequences and result in the cancellation of goods and services that are dissimilar to those of the “earlier mark”.
Do you want to reuse the IPKat content? Please refer to our
Policies section.
If you have any queries or requests for permission, please get in touch with the IPKat team.
.png)
Comments
Post a Comment
All comments must be moderated by a member of the IPKat team before they appear on the blog. Comments will not be allowed if the contravene the IPKat policy that readers' comments should not be obscene or defamatory; they should not consist of ad hominem attacks on members of the blog team or other comment-posters and they should make a constructive contribution to the discussion of the post on which they purport to comment.
It is also the IPKat policy that comments should not be made completely anonymously, and users should use a consistent name or pseudonym (which should not itself be defamatory or obscene, or that of another real person), either in the "identity" field, or at the beginning of the comment. Current practice is to, however, allow a limited number of comments that contravene this policy, provided that the comment has a high degree of relevance and the comment chain does not become too difficult to follow.
Learn more here: http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/p/want-to-complain.html