The Register brings news of what looks like some interesting litigation between phone giants Nokia and a couple of nuisance competitors, handset makers Sagem (France) and Vitelcom (Spain). Alas, the news item doesn't tell us the things we really want to know. For example
* Which IP rights is it alleged that Sagem and Vitelcom have infringed? Could be one or more of the following: national trade mark rights, Community trade mark rights, national registered design right, national unregistered design right, Community registered design right, Community unregistered design right, artistic copyright, patents - or an action for unfair competition, passing off or slavish imitation.
* In which country or countries is the litigation being launched? Given that handsets are not only highly portable but also importable and exportable, litigation could happen almost anywhere -- perhaps with the prospect of (i) a battle as to which court or courts should retain jurisdiction and/or (ii) the chance of a pan-European court order.
The IPKat begs his readers -- if you know the answers to any of these questions, do please post them as Comments below.
More on handsets here, here and here
* Which IP rights is it alleged that Sagem and Vitelcom have infringed? Could be one or more of the following: national trade mark rights, Community trade mark rights, national registered design right, national unregistered design right, Community registered design right, Community unregistered design right, artistic copyright, patents - or an action for unfair competition, passing off or slavish imitation.
* In which country or countries is the litigation being launched? Given that handsets are not only highly portable but also importable and exportable, litigation could happen almost anywhere -- perhaps with the prospect of (i) a battle as to which court or courts should retain jurisdiction and/or (ii) the chance of a pan-European court order.
The IPKat begs his readers -- if you know the answers to any of these questions, do please post them as Comments below.
More on handsets here, here and here
BIG FIGHT IN VIEW FOR HANDSET MAKERS - BUT WHERE'S THE VENUE?
![BIG FIGHT IN VIEW FOR HANDSET MAKERS - BUT WHERE'S THE VENUE?]()
Reviewed by Jeremy
on
Thursday, November 04, 2004
Rating:
Follow the IPKat on LinkedIn 
![[Guest post] Thou shalt not discriminate the Lego block over any other kind of product – GRUR speaks out on C-211/24](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgWJYQUJNvYydrZcjwSHPuxd14xX3_48aBusHKBogY-Wg1BPSJSABbFFjmGiUV3aqG2npP9xYaIl1vtWK5AsqGOQPgRD2TWFLhyyc4xGm1fHDD-tt9kHcrSSgAyju2P9wSKz0VW6h7D5MD4Hxd9vREyxKYzlMRNXxxtxc3DiNsXppfVaxgSxAMV/s72-c/21742619125_7c9e53cd39_o.png)
![[Guest post] Comparison of wine and gin: the EUIPO’s unquestionable Similarity Tool](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiNfTEBXiPVS0XjZi4mNE1OtXLxXiEp1PUgcUK7MMMXlfyTkO5SMXv-VCMXXNdS_F1XdMMxYca1VbBTGvvDeTVpo5x-5YwR7atQJmK3x32T8LACpf4308kht3nEtaxPwEPcGGrB0s5xjGktmQPOiVwPVLRO5JbW19qupc7xUtiVutvaWHow0OpBkA/s72-c/Picture%201.jpg)
![[Guest post] Muddying the waters of copyright – a rapid reaction to today’s IPEC decision which sees the sinking of the WaterRower’s claims for copyright protection](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEh7chFANC7ppmZl4_nlR6_hZEcg6cOhVEJNVXqki4p82BoVlcLFotuOXzHWYD5lKLiiK_kRoWeXmJjjaV2DpoKsAWq8U3LFioO5W_841a9gcfDIFjvZWcGqfnr0jWJNtyXptIYR_8bxCssaDkJ9KMokuSqy1g65Il7p2hPwo4MfRCEGoUPQJesvbg/s72-w400-c-h189/Screenshot%202024-11-11%20at%2018.20.45.png)
Posts
According to this article on ZDnet [French], the lawsuit against Sagem is being filed in Germany.
ReplyDeleteIMHO, in this country artistic copyright might not be granted to telephones' appearance.
Frédéric
The Vitelcom suit is for infringement of patents covering GSM and GPRS, according to http://www.vnunet.com/news/1159174 (among other sources). No word as to venue, other than that it is a "European complaint".
ReplyDeleteThe Sagem complaint alleges that a Sagem phone (the myX5-2) infringes Nokia's registered design - according to http://www.reuters.co.uk/newsPackageArticle.jhtml?type=businessNews&storyID=615428§ion=finance.